West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff 2016

Share this:

The word “roadkill” probably congers up a vivid image in your mind, but I’m guessing it’s not “dinner.” Not unless you happen to live in West Virginia and are familiar with the world famous West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff, that is. Being an adventurous eater and wanna be chef myself, this eccentric cooking competition had been on my radar for some time. Finally, last September, I bit the bullet and threw my hat into the ring. Here’s how I won third place in the 2016 West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff.

roadkill cookoff

This was our Judge’s Table. Bright, festive and overflowing with southwestern flair. Image credit: Cherri Megasko

Choosing My Protein for the Roadkill Cookoff

The first decision I had to make was what to cook. It may sound simple, but I struggled with it for a few weeks. I knew I wanted something the audience had probably never tasted before, but for this crowd that was a tall order. I did some research on previous years and knew that rabbit, squirrel, opossum, beaver and even bear were yesterday’s news. I found a distributor of specialty meats in California and finally settled on iguana.

Deciding on My Dish for the Roadkill Cookoff

With the protein decision out of the way the next decision was easy – what dish do I make? In keeping with the rationality of iguana I knew it had to be southwestern. Tacos first came to mind, but they had been done to death in this competition. I decided to do a tostada, but call it a nacho. With a little help from my friends, I decided my slogan would be “I wanna iguana nachos.”

Practice Makes Perfect, Even for the Roadkill Cookoff

I started to work right away getting my table décor together and working on my event signage. I also ordered one pound of iguana meat so I could work on my recipe and make sure the cooking process made sense. We didn’t have access to electricity and weren’t allowed to use generators. So all our cooking had to be done burning wood, charcoal or propane. And just for clarification, contest rules state at least 25 percent of your protein had to be your “roadkill” meat. I used 25 percent iguana and 75 percent chicken thighs. (To do 100 percent roadkill meat would be far too expensive, since we had to prepare enough food for 2000 people.)

roadkill cookoff

This was my iguana nacho prototype … pretty, perfect and delicious! Image credit: Cherri Megasko

Roadkill Cookoff Competition Frenzy

Greg and I took our camper up to the Marlinton area the day before the cookoff. I was unsuccessful at recruiting anyone else to help us, so it was just him and me. I set my alarm for 2:00 a.m. and began the prep work of shredding lettuce and cilantro and slicing cherry tomatoes and jalapenos. I finished just in time to pack everything up and get to the contest venue right on time.

roadkill cookoff

Our team name for the 2016 West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff was “You Hit Em, We Spit Em.” Image credit: Cherri Megasko

The first thing I noticed that made me nervous was that all the other teams had multiple helpers. I think five was the least number I counted. Other teams also had very elaborate set-ups – one was even a food truck made of wood that was assembled with power tools. We had three tables … we didn’t even have a tent covering.

Although a little shaken by our obvious newby standing, I was determined to give it my best shot. When service started it started with a bang and at about an hour and a half into the competition our line was probably 100 people deep. People began telling us they had been in line for over an hour. So, we switched gears, and instead of building each tostada to look pretty and perfect, we started putting all the ingredients into a 2 oz. serving cup, topping it with a couple of chips and handing it to the customers. That helped move through the line much faster. We actually continued to serve until past closing time, far longer than most other teams who ran out of food. (I am absolutely sure the other teams did not come prepared to feed 2000 people.)

roadkill cookoff

We were allowed to serve side dishes and a drink to the judges. We kept everything – down to the drinks – true to the southwestern theme. Image credit: Cherri Megasko

Roadkill Cookoff Award Ceremony

I left Greg to handle most of the cleaning and packing up while I scurried over to the award ceremony. I was sunburnt and sweaty and my feet were killing me, but I still remained hopeful for one of the five cash prizes. The prizes were:

  • People’s Choice (Tasters each got a ballot that they used to vote for their favorite)
  • Showmanship (Awarded by the judges for design of serving space and dress/demeanor of team)
  • Judge’s First Place (based on taste, originality, and presentation of the meal, and showmanship)
  • Judge’s Second Place ((based on taste, originality, and presentation of the meal, and showmanship)
  • Judge’s Third Place (based on taste, originality, and presentation of the meal, and showmanship)

Happily, we won third place. It was enough to make me feel that all the time, effort and investment were worth it. I fully planned to compete in the 2017 competition as well – I even know my protein and dishes – but Greg’s and my travel schedule doesn’t allow it. I’ll be back some day though, and this time I’ll be eyeing first place!

roadkill cookoff

This simple cutting board “trophy” is one of my hardest earned awards in life. I’m very proud of my third place finish. Image credit: Cherri Megasko

For more information on the Marlinton, Virginia, Autumn Harvest Festival and West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff, check out Roadkill Food Festival.





Share this:

22 thoughts on “West Virginia Roadkill Cookoff 2016

  1. James Thomas

    Very cool to read about and it sounds like you went at it full tilt. What a great experience. Look forward to reading about 2018.

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Thanks, James – It was a blast (other than the sunburn and sweat). I can’t wait to do it again and I will for sure be writing about it.

  2. Victoria

    Oh my gosh never!!! As a vegetarian I wouldn’t do this! But at least the animals were already dead and being repurposed so that’s actually a good thing!

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Victoria – I hate to bust your vegetarian bubble, but the meat isn’t actually roadkill. It just has to be something that COULD BE roadkill.

  3. Claudia

    Oh such an interesting experience. I didnt even know this existed. But you were all in! Congratz on third place !

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Thanks, Claudia – I was all-in, indeed! I can’t wait for 2018 when I get to compete again.

  4. Rob

    Congratulations coming in 3rd place is awesome, and feeding 2000 people is a feat unto itself. I have eaten a lot of different things but never iguana. The Roadkill Cook-off sounds fun and I would love to attend to try all the different proteins, definitely cool concept for a cook-off.

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Thanks, Rob! Of course I went in aiming for first, but I was very happy with third. Especially since so many of the contestants were multiple-year competitors.

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Sofia – Looking back on it, it was tons of fun. But in the heat of battle it was exhausting! LOL

  5. Mel | The Wandering Darlings

    Wow I’ve never heard of an iguana meal before. Bet it was a different taste! Road kill cook off judges must have some strong stomachs as half ioff the animals you mentioned I could never imagine eating. Congrats on your trophy

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Mel – In it’s raw state iguana meat is red and smells unpleasant. But when cooked, it’s actually very good.

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Thanks, Donna. I’m just happy we had been given the 2 oz. serving cups so I had a Plan B for serving.

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Really? It’s actually pretty famous. It’s appeared in several international magazines and was even on one episode of Bizarre Foods with Andrew Zimmern.

  6. Cat

    Congratulations on winning 3rd place! Choosing iguana as your protein is an interesting and unique decision. Would love to give it a try one day!

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Cat – I first tried iguana when I was traveling in Bonaire. I had it in a soup and it was delicious prepared that way as well.

  7. Chrysoula

    Congratulations for winning third place. It is a big accomplishment since you were only two without help and you had to feed 2.000 people!!!

    1. Cherri Megasko Post author

      Thank you, Chrysoula. I do feel like it was a big accomplishment and I can’t wait to compete again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *